Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has. Margaret Mead

Devon County Council cabinet rejects my motion to back retention of community hospital buildings

Wednesday, 12 September 2018 2 Comments by Claire

Devon County Council’s all Conservative cabinet has rejected my motion to strongly support the retention of all community hospital buildings and strongly resist any plans to sell them off.

Responding to the cabinet recommendation to full council to “note that this is a matter for the NHS” I said that it was entirely appropriate and proper that the council should take a position on this, that the loss of beds in our community hospitals was one of the most controversial issues of recent times.

Over 200 community hospital beds have been lost since 2012, to thousands of people protesting, either in person, in writing, or at demonstrations waving placards.

Now NHS Property Services has ‘acquired’ 12 community hospitals in Eastern Devon and is charging around £3m a year, which is currently being paid for by NHS England. However, this is only a temporary arrangement and NHS England will not cover this (absurd) cost long-term.

I pointed out that Devon County Council administers the Health and Adult Care Scrutiny Committee (that I am a member of) which is the only legal check on health services in Devon.  It is clear that local people are relying on councillors to stand up for them and represent their views.
I even read out a passage from the Local Government Association website which defined a councillor’s primary role as representing their ward and the people who live in it. 

I was supported by other councillors attending the meeting, including Martin Shaw (my Indie colleague who seconded the motion), Alistair Dewhirst (Libdem), Rob Hannaford (Labour) and Carol Whitton (Labour).

Unusually, almost all members of the cabinet spoke on this issue. All were opposed for a variety of reasons, including claims that we cannot influence the NHS in this way, that the CCG is excellent to work with and that Holsworthy and Okehampton Hospitals are being retained, so all the community needs to do is work to achieve this.

It isn’t quite this simple in my experience!

Even Phil Norrey, the chief executive added his view, which was that any capital receipts (funding that is the result of a sale) should be retained locally.  A sensible point and a good backstop position.

I wasn’t able to respond to these points as I had already had my say, but there was absolutely no argument made by any cabinet councillor that justified their rejection on my motion.

The full cabinet recommendation is as follows:  “That council be asked to note that this is a matter for the NHS but this council will work in partnership to influence decision making appropriate to individual circumstances, including population need and the quality of building.”

I look forward to 4 October, full council, when the motion will be debated and determined by all 60 councillors.

Here’s the webcast. See item 12, with the list of councillor names that you can click on to see what they had to say! -

If you disagree with the cabinet recommendation, please do feel free to email your local councillor!

Pic:  Kicking off speeches at an NHS rally in Exeter in February, where community hospitals were high on the agenda


1. At 10:17 pm on 12th Sep Roger Giles wrote:

As we know there is little or no democracy, and no public accountability, in the NHS.
It is profoundly disappointing therefore, that the Conservative Cabinet of Devon County Council (which is a democratic body) would not support Claire’s request for DCC to press for the retention of Devon’s community hospitals. The argument made by the Conservatives was that ‘this is a matter for the NHS’ . To do as they wish, and ignoring the needs and views of Devon people? That is reprehensible. Especially as the DCC Chief Executive pointed out that receipts from disposal of Devon hospitals declared ‘surplus to requirements’ might well be used outside Devon.

2. At 09:39 pm on 17th Sep Val Ranger wrote:

The Conservative party in both EDDC and DCC have made it clear that they put party policy before the needs or wishes of residents when it comes to our local hospitals. I can think of no issue that has greater public support than the retention of our local hospitals and services yet time after time these views are dismissed by the ruling parties who appear completely out of touch with what is happening in our hospitals both to staff via the pressures they are under and the patients they are trying to serve. It is impossible to have any respect at all for these councillors.

Submit A Comment